Buyer in Good Faith Only Applies to Registered Land: A Philippine Legal Perspective

When it comes to buying real estate in the Philippines, the term “buyer in good faith” often comes up, especially in land disputes. Many buyers assume that as long as they purchase a property without knowledge of any legal problems or claims, they are automatically protected. However, under Philippine law, this protection only applies if the land is registered under the Torrens system.

Let’s explore what this means and why it’s important.

Understanding “Buyer in Good Faith”

A buyer in good faith is someone who purchases a property:

• For valuable consideration (i.e., they paid for it),

• Without knowledge of any defect or competing claims over the property, and

• After exercising due diligence, such as inspecting the title and property status.

This legal doctrine is intended to protect innocent purchasers who act in good faith and rely on the apparent validity of the title.

But here’s the key limitation: this protection applies only to lands that are registered under the Torrens system.

Registered vs. Unregistered Land

Registered Land

Registered land refers to property with a Certificate of Title issued by the Land Registration Authority (LRA) under the Torrens system. Once registered, the state guarantees the title’s validity. The registered owner is presumed to have a legal and absolute title, and third parties can rely on what appears on the certificate of title.

Thus, a buyer in good faith and for value is protected—even if it turns out later that the seller acquired the land through fraud, as long as the buyer had no notice of any such defect and relied on a clean title.

Unregistered Land

Unregistered land does not have a Torrens title. Instead, ownership is often supported by tax declarations, deeds of sale, or other public documents. These documents do not guarantee ownership, and any buyer is expected to investigate thoroughly, not only the paperwork but also the actual possession and historical claims to the land.

In such cases, the doctrine of buyer in good faith does not apply in the same way. Even if a buyer acts in good faith, they can still lose the property if another person can prove a better or older claim to it. The courts do not recognize the same level of protection for buyers of unregistered land.

Key Supreme Court Rulings

The Philippine Supreme Court has consistently ruled on this principle. For example:

• In Spouses Aquino v. Frondozo (G.R. No. 174632, January 20, 2009), the Court held that a buyer of unregistered land must prove not only good faith but also a clear and superior right to the property. Mere good faith is not enough.

• In Tenio-Obsequio v. Court of Appeals (G.R. No. 107967, March 1, 1994), the Court emphasized that only buyers of registered land are protected when purchasing from someone who appears to have title.

  
  

These rulings reinforce the idea that the law protects buyers only when they rely on an official, government-issued title, not private agreements or tax declarations.

What Should Buyers Do?

If you're looking to buy land in the Philippines, here are some best practices:

1. Always check if the land is titled. Ask for a certified true copy from the Registry of Deeds.

2. Verify the title’s authenticity. Check if there are annotations like mortgages, lis pendens, or adverse claims.

3. Inspect the property personally. Ensure that the person selling it is in possession and has no disputes with neighbors or relatives.

4. Consult a lawyer or broker. Have all documents reviewed before signing or paying.

   
   

Final Thoughts

In Philippine law, "buyer in good faith" is not a magic phrase that guarantees protection. It only provides strong legal shield if the property is registered under the Torrens system. Buyers of unregistered land have a higher burden of proof and much less protection.

If you’re planning to buy real estate, make sure the land is titled and your due diligence is thorough. When it comes to property, peace of mind is worth the paperwork.

Source: Ziggurat Real Estate